[Jinyong Discussion 1] Dugu Qiubai vs. Dongfang Bubai

last SG · 2006-05-08T23:53:31+00:00

no lah .. 'cos if you dissect Ming .. it will be Ri and Yue.

Icemoon SG

The age old debate!

Very Happy

stellazio SG

dugu jiubai is the best!

vince69 SG

ok, come here to raise the rating Smile

laurence82 SG

can list the characters?

i very luan, long time no read

even my Three Kingdoms also forgotten liao

DriftingGuy SG

I want to side with dugu qiubai.. but ultimately dong fang bu bai will win.. Laughing The dugu jiu jian cannot defeat dong fang bu bu bai's deadly inner energy

vince69 SG

Dugu Qiubai will lose
reason .. He want to be defeated

Dongfang Bubai will win
reason ... He have the confidence he won't lose

Laughing

RaTtY81 SG

yea but dugu qiubai vs huang shan would b better.
cos huang shan defeated dugu b4 with jiuyin zhenjin but at tat time he haven master the 9th stroke of dugu jiujian tats po qi shi.(counter qi). when he finally master the 9th stroke, think huang shan died or retired from martial world n dugu nvr go find him duel again.

RaTtY81 SG

dugu po qi shi is for those with great internal energy tats y i think dugu will win.

vince69 SG

which list?

laurence82 SG

Both sides, altho i more familiar with Xiao Ao Jiang Hu

Icemoon SG

but can dooku match dongfang's speed, that is the issue.

or else like Linghu Chong liddat .. cannot exploit any weakness.

laurence82 SG

exploit weakness?

anyone got watch Shuang Long story? also set during the founding of Tang Dynasty?

Icemoon SG

ya .. 'cos Linghu Chong works by exploitng weakness.

There was one time at night .. he almost lost his life to an average or under-average swordsmen from I think Green City Sect. Guess why. Laughing

RaTtY81 SG

i think dugu will still win ba.

vince69 SG

that time different, think that was just after he kenna big time and lost all his inner strength liao.

laurence82 SG

coz he cant see the weakness?

vince69 SG

ok, list some for you here...

main character
Ling Hu Chong - 5 mt sect (heads the nunery arm)
Ren Ying Ying - maiden of Hei Mu Ya
Ren Wo Xing - Father of Ren Ying Ying, ex boss of Hei Mu Ya
Dong Fang Bu Bai - boss of Hei Mu Ya (most powerful character in the novel)

the rest are mostly small fry in the novel
Yue Bu Chun - one time teacher of Ling Hu Chong
Mei Zhung 4 Gents - 4 useless bumps
Smile

DriftingGuy SG

Is there someone who is your weakness? Embarassed

Icemoon SG

hmm .. in the first place Dugu 9 Sword requires little inner strength to master.

I think if Linghu Chong kenna a heavy blow, he is gone for sure.

Icemoon SG

They not really useless leh. Their skills considered quite good in the story.